Monarch
Wayne's Word Index Noteworthy Plants Trivia Lemnaceae Biology 101 Botany Scenic Wildflowers Trains Spiders & Insects Search
 Increase The Size Of Display On Your Monitor:    PCs Type Control (Ctrl) +     MACs Type Command (⌘) + 
Milkweeds & Monarch Butterfly
W.P. Armstrong Summer 2024
Cameras Used: Nikon D-90Nikon D-3200Sony HX-60Sony T-10Sony W-300

Introduction: Milkweeds (Asclepias) have always been one of my favorite plants, particularly their fascinating relationship with insects. In fact, pollination of native milkweeds was a favorite topic in my plant ID course at Palomar College. During the summer of 2024 I became especially interested in monarch butterflies visiting the native species (A. fasciculata) at my home in Twin Oaks Valley, San Diego County. In August, monarch butterflies laid eggs on the milkweeds; however, most caterpillars vanished before reaching their pupal (chrysalis) stage. I suspect a resident western fence lizard (Sceloporus occidentalis) had something to do with some of this disappearance. It apparently was not affected by ingested milkweed toxins in the caterpillars. I have included my images with 5 different cameras from the past 5 decades on this page.

In my limited experience, caterpillars in my milkweed garden usually did not reach the critical pupation stage where they develop into a chrysalis. Even the last chrysalis in my milkweed garden was destroyed by parasitoid tachinid fly larvae and Argentine ants. The remedy appears to be raising the larvae indoors within a terrarium or plastic enclosure and keeping them well-supplied with milkweed leaves from your garden. There are some excellent references on the Internet with instructions on rearing caterpillars & chrysalises (pupae) indoors and releasing adults when their wings are sufficiently dry for flight.


Based on DNA comparisons, the milkweed family Asclepiadaceae has been
reduced to subfamily Asclepiadoideae within dogbane family Apocynaceae.

1. Don't Plant Tropical Milkweed: Asclepias curassavica
2. The Truly Remarkable Life Cycle of Monarch Butterfly
3. Other Milkweed Visitors With Warning Coloration
4. The Remarkable Pollination of Milkweeds (Asclepias)  

1. Don't Plant Tropical Milkweeds in Southern California.

The red-flowered tropical milkweed (Asclepias curassavica) photographed on island of Moorea in French Polynesia. This was a Palomar College field trip led by marine biologist Lester Knapp en route to Marlon Brando's tropical atoll of Tetiaroa. This species has become naturalized in San Diego County.

According to following reference by K.R. Nail, L. Drizd & K.J. Voorhies (2019), monarchs have a worldwide distribution.

Nail K.R., Drizd L., and Voorhies K.J. (2019) "Butterflies Across the Globe: A Synthesis of the Current Status and Characteristics of Monarch (Danaus plexippus) Populations Worldwide." Front. Ecol. Evol. 7:362. doi: 10.3389/fevo.2019.00362

Link To Excellent Monarch Joint Venture: Summary of Monarch Global Distribution

"While monarchs are native to North America, they've spread throughout much of the world during the past 200 years (Nail et al., 2019). They currently inhabit over 90 countries, islands, and island groups (including French Polynesia) but differ in their morphology, migration and overwintering patterns, natural enemies, larval diet, and genetics."

"Monarchs arrived in North America from a migratory ancestor, common to both Danaus plexippus and D. erippus. As the last ice-age receded 20,000 years ago, the monarch population occupying the southern USA and northern Mexico began to grow and expand their range and migration annually. These expansions were stimulated by the abundance of milkweed that was growing, exploiting the novel habitat uncovered by the glacial recession. The population underwent three separate dispersions into South America, westwards to Oceania and Australia, and east across the Atlantic."

"Researchers are still unsure exactly how and why the monarch made its journey across the ocean. A few hypotheses have been formulated. It is possible that they were transported by the numerous ships that made the long voyage across the Pacific Ocean. Because larvae have to move around a lot to find suitable pupation sites, and since milkweed can be found around shipyards, it is possible that the larvae were transferred onto ships where they could travel a long distance before emerging. It is also possible that overwintering adult monarchs landed on ships and then were carried across during the winter. Even these hypotheses seem a little far-fetched, however. It is most likely that humans were involved in the process, but it is not known to what extent. Monarchs in North America can fly over 2,200 km during their migration, so it is possible that some made the journey on their own!"

"Monarch dispersal across the Atlantic was closely tied with the availability of milkweed larval host plants. Both Gomphocarpus fruticosus and Asclepias curassavica were prominently established in the northern Africa and Iberian Peninsula before initial monarch sightings east of the Atlantic Ocean. More recent anthropogenically introduced host plants in Southern Spain are thriving and seem to be expanding into the Mediterranean region where a favorable climate and growing conditions only appear to be encouraging the milkweed spread (specifically Gomphocarpus physocarpus). With established host plants, monarch butterflies that were blown off of their migratory pathway from North America to Mexico could still successfully colonize areas where host plants were available, like southern Spain and Portugal. While larvae or butterflies could have hitchhiked across the Atlantic, rare monarch sightings on the coast of the UK, likely caused by winds blowing vagrant monarchs across the sea, show that human interference is not necessary for monarchs to cross the Atlantic Ocean."


It seems to me that if you carefully cut back your evergreen tropical milkweeds at the end of summer they may not adversely effect monarch butterflies; however, some authorities strongly recommend that you don't grow this species in southern California. See the following from Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation:

"Don't Grow Tropical Milkweed" by Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation

Go To Online Link For: Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation

"Tropical milkweed (Asclepias curassavica) is a non-native milkweed that has exploded in popularity in response to the demand for milkweed. It is simple to propagate, allowing growers to rapidly produce the plant for quick sale. The plant is also attractive, both to humans and monarchs, providing flowers and lush green foliage throughout the growing season – and that’s a problem.

Tropical milkweed becomes a problem when planted in temperate areas where it does not die back in winter. A protozoan parasite of monarch butterflies, Ophryocystis elektroscirrha or OE for short, can travel with monarchs visiting the plants and become deposited on leaves. When caterpillars hatch and start eating the plant, they ingest the OE. High OE levels in adult monarchs have been linked to lower migration success in the eastern monarch population, as well as reductions in body mass, lifespan, mating success, and flight ability.

When native milkweeds die back after blooming, the parasite dies along with them so that each summer’s monarch population feeds on fresh, parasite-free foliage. In contrast, tropical milkweed that remains evergreen through winter allows for OE levels to build up on the plant over time, meaning successive generations of monarch caterpillars feeding on the plant can be exposed to dangerous levels of OE."

Dark areas on chrysalis may indicate parasites:

(1) Bacteria or virus infection.

(2) Protozoan parasite (Ophryocystis elektroscirrha).

(3) Chalcid wasp, tachinid fly or parasitic wasp laid eggs inside larva or pupa.

Just before they pupate, monarch larvae spin a silk mat from which they hang upside down by their last pair of prolegs. The silk comes from the spinneret on the bottom of the head. Even at this late stage in their short lives, they are still vulnerable.


2. The Remarkable Monarch Butterfly

Monarch Eggs Laid On Asclepias fasciculatus


Minute Larval Hatchling On Asclepias fasciculatus


Caterpillar (Larva) On Asclepias fasciculatus

I originally counted only 2 eggs on these leaves; however, there were 4!


Pupa Stage Referred To As A Chrysalis

Monarch larva (caterpillar) and chrysalis (right). Unlike moths, butterfly larvae do not spin cocoons.

Butterflies and moths belong to the large insect order Lepidoptera. They have complete metamorphosis (holometabolous) consisting of a egg, larva (caterpillar), pupa and adult (imago). The fully-formed, quiescent pupa of a butterfly is also called a chrysalis. Moth larva may spin an outer cocoon that contains pupa, or transform directly into a pupa without a cocoon. For example, the tomato hornworm (hawkmoth larva) burrows into the ground and transforms into a large pupa resembling a picnic jug. Larvae of most moth species spin a silken cocoon in which the pupa develops.

Monarch butterflies have a remarkable migration cycle each year. Since they cannot survive the cold winters of the northern United States and Canada they must migrate thousands of miles in order to complete their life cycle. Unlike birds, the Monarchs who go south do not return where they were born. It is their offspring who make this long, arduous journey. All of the Monarchs east of the Rocky Mountains overwinter on forested mountain tops in central Mexico within the Transvolcanic Range. All of the Monarchs west of the Rockies travel south along the Pacific Coast, where they overwinter in trees from north of San Francisco to San Diego. They are distasteful to some predators because of toxic chemicals ingested by the larvae while feeding on their host milkweeds (Asclepias).

Release Of 1st Adult Monarch From Wayne's Word Milkweed Planter


Adult Monarch With Aposomatic (Warning) Coloration

Male monarch butterfly at Huntington Botanical Gardens in San Marino, California. Note the black spot (scent gland) on one of the veins in each hind wing. Males use the pheromones produced by these glands to make themselves attractive to females. Females have thicker veins and no black dots.

This female monarch butterfly came from my insect collection for Cal State University, Los Angeles entomology class over 50 years ago.

Because of an accumulation of steroidal glycosides during its larval feeding stage, the adult Monarch butterfly is toxic and distasteful. Insect-eating birds soon recognize this brightly colored species and reject it as a food source. Another butterfly with similar colorations and markings is the Viceroy (Limenitis archippus). For many years, textbooks cited the Monarch and Viceroy as a classic example of Batesian mimicry, in which the Viceroy mimic was perfectly palatable to would-be predators. Recent studies indicate that the Viceroy is not an acceptable meal for birds, and therefore, these two species represent an example of Mullerian mimicry.


3. Other Milkweed Visitors With Warning Coloration

Many insects with bad taste or toxins have bright warning colorations to deter possible predators. This survival adaptation occurs in tiny milkweed aphids and colorful milkweed bugs that ingest toxins from their milkweed host.

Large milkweed bugs (Oncopeltus fasciatus) on milkweed seed pod (technically called a follicle) with several seeds. Milkweed "parachute seeds" are dispersed into the wind, another marvelous adaptation for this fascinating genus of flowering plants.

The single carpel of a follicle splits open along one seam. When completely opened, the carpel resembles a thick, dried leaf. It is easy to see that the single carpel of a follicle is a modified, seed-bearing leaf (megasporophyll).


4. The Remarkable Pollination of Milkweeds (Asclepias)

The Remarkable Bisexual Milkweed Blossom




Close-up view of the corona and gynostegium of desert milkweed (Asclepias erosa). The corona includes five petaloid appendages arising from the filaments of the five stamens, including the hoods and horns. The gynostegium is a characteristic milkweed structure formed by the fusion of the stamens with the stigma. Pollen masses (pollinia) from adjacent anther sacs are attached by thread-like translator arms which are joined together at the corpusculum. The translator is snagged by the leg of an insect that inadvertently slips down into the stigmatic slit. As the insect flies away, the pollinia are pulled out of the anther sacs like a pair of saddlebags, and are carried off to another milkweed blossom. Only larger insects (such as strong wasps) can pull away with the pollinia attached to their legs. The legs of smaller, feeble flying insects may remain trapped in the stigmatic slits and never leave the flower's death trap.

Tarantula Hawks On Rush Milkweed Asclepias subulata

As I have stated on Wayne's Word, I am never certain about the sex of tarantula hawk wasps, or if it is safe to handle one. In general, males are apparently a little smaller than females, and several species are reported in my area. I am not about to allow one to sting me just to see if it is a stinging female or nonstinging male, especially since the sting is reportedly excruciating. Females often have coiled antennae; however, they can apparently also straighten their antennae like wasps in my photo. I also don't trust antennae color to determine their sex. According to Bugguide.net, Pepsis mildei has orange antennae. Other species in the Twin Oaks Valley area have black antennae. One thing for sure, these large, back wasps with red wings are definitely attracted to milkweed blossoms.


Return To WAYNE'S WORD Home Page
Return To NOTEWORTHY PLANTS Page
Go To Biology GEE WHIZ TRIVIA Page
Go To The LEMNACEAE ON-LINE Page